Mondeto
email us
  • Home
  • An Easy Language?
  • Global Education
  • Language Apprenticeship
  • What You Need
  • Online Resources
  • Contact Us
  • Test

Is Bicultural Perspective Enough?

2/10/2011

2 Comments

 
Picture
According to ACARA, responsible for developing Australia's national curriculum: The most direct means for learning about and engaging with Indigenous communities and Asian countries and people is to learn their languages.

This constitutes fuzzy thinking because it confuses an effect at National level with an effect at the level of each individual child for whom we are responsible.

How are our students realistically going to learn “their languages”? We almost  never succeed in teaching students even one foreign language well enough to exchange genuine cultural insights.

Although it is traditional to act as if 100 students having insight into 1 foreign culture each, is the same thing as 100 students knowing something about 100 (or even 10) foreign cultures, it isn’t: Understanding Japan is not understanding Asia. Asian cultures have a vast diversity of languages, religions, economic and political systems, artforms and other priorities. Even if our current system worked perfectly, which of course it doesn’t, we would still be educating bicultural graduates, not multicultural ones and that is a bar too low for the education of global citizens.

Indigenous and Asian cultures are diverse and important, and the plurals are important. Putting plurals on the goals and then delivering singles at implementation does nothing to increase the trust with which Australians view academic advice.

To achieve the cross-curiculum priorities for individual Australians we need pathways such as ALL to keep our delivery general at the F-6 stage, so that children really do get to combine consistent cumulative language learning with a broad and shifting intercultural perspective, responsive to student interests.

This slideshow  introduces some of the classes of primary children who are currently learning Esperanto and are available to bring some personal significance to parts of the globe that would otherwise be beyond reach.






2 Comments
Gordon Coleman
2/10/2011 13:53:33

Can somebody tell me why Finland can run a perfectly effective language programme in their schools and we can't?



Having just returned I spoke to a lady and her daughter. The girl is learning Finnish, English and German at school and Polish at home.

When I asked her mother if she (the mother) spoke English se gave a look as if I'd suggested she'd stepped in something unpleasant! "Of course!", was her reply


Next year she will begin to learn Swedish and if I remember correctly in year 7 she'll be starting a fifth language!



She is ten years old and this is the norm not an exception.

Reply
Penny Vos link
2/10/2011 14:45:31

I think that it has a lot to do with expectation and modeling. Do you agree?
Finnish children hardly know any monolingual adults, they know lots of multilingual ones.
Therefore, that is what they expect for themselves.
Australian experts talk about the monolingual mindset as being our problem and I reason that Esperanto is the perfect tool to eradicate it as it could generate thousands of bilingual role models faster than any other strategy.
It sure would be nice if ACARA would show a bit of leadership to that end.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Penny Vos

    See also: Childhood Blog 
    and Global Blog :-)

    Archives

    July 2016
    September 2015
    December 2012
    May 2012
    March 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    June 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010

    Categories

    All
    Esperanto
    Learning
    Popi
    Video

    RSS Feed

    Translate
    015